Asset vs. Non-Asset Transportation: Which Model is Right for Your Bottom Line?

You've just landed a major client, and they need their product shipped across the country. Fast. You've got options: Hire a carrier with their own trucks and drivers, or work with a broker who connects you with carriers.

‍

Which one will get your product there on time and under budget? Which one will make your client happy and keep your bottom line healthy? The choice between asset-based and non-asset-based transportation isn't always obvious.  In this post, we'll break down the key differences, and help you figure out which model is the right fit for your business.‍

‍

Understanding Asset-Based Transportation

‍

Asset-based carriers are the traditional trucking companies you're probably familiar with. They own and operate their own fleet of trucks, trailers, and other equipment, and employ their own drivers.

‍

Advantages of Asset-Based Carriers:

‍

• Direct Control: You have more control over your shipments, from scheduling to routing.
• Dedicated Capacity: You can secure capacity even during peak seasons.
• Specialized Expertise: Some asset-based carriers specialize in certain types of freight or industries.

‍

Disadvantages of Asset-Based Carriers:

• Higher Costs:  Owning and maintaining equipment is expensive, which can translate to higher rates.
• Limited Flexibility:  Their network and capacity are limited to their own assets.
• Risk of Underutilization: If demand fluctuates, their assets may sit idle, costing you money.

‍

Understanding Non-Asset Based Transportation

‍

Non-asset-based transportation brokers, sometimes called "freight brokers" or "3PLs," don't own their own trucks. Instead, they act as intermediaries, connecting shippers with carriers who have the right equipment and capacity for your needs.

‍

Advantages of Non-Asset Based Brokers:

• Greater Flexibility: They can tap into a vast network of carriers, finding the best fit for your shipment.
• Cost-Effectiveness: Their large volume often allows them to negotiate better rates with carriers.
• Broader Range of Services:  Many brokers offer additional services like warehousing, customs brokerage, and supply chain consulting.

‍

Disadvantages of Non-Asset Based Brokers:

• Less Direct Control: You have less control over which carrier handles your shipment.
• Potential Communication Issues:  More parties involved can sometimes lead to miscommunication.

‍

Key Factors to Consider

‍

The best choice for your business depends on your specific needs and priorities. Here are some key questions to ask yourself:

‍

How often do you ship and how much?

If you have frequent, high-volume shipments, asset-based might offer the stability you need. If your needs are more sporadic or seasonal, non-asset-based flexibility could be advantageous.

‍

What types of freight do you ship, and do you have any special needs?  

If you require specialized equipment or handling, an asset-based carrier with the right expertise might be your best bet.

‍

What's your budget?

Non-asset-based brokers can often secure competitive rates, but might not always be the cheapest option if you need specialized services.

‍

Where are you shipping to and from?  

Asset-based carriers might have limited geographic reach, while non-asset-based brokers can typically find carriers anywhere.

‍

Do you need additional services beyond transportation?

Many non-asset-based brokers offer a full suite of logistics services, which could simplify your supply chain.

‍

When Asset-Based Makes Sense

‍

• High-volume shippers:  If you ship large volumes regularly, you can benefit from dedicated capacity and consistent service.
• Specialized needs:  If you require specific equipment or expertise, an asset-based carrier focused on your industry can be invaluable.
• Need for control: If having direct control over your shipments is paramount, owning the assets gives you that power.

When Non-Asset Based Makes Sense

‍

• Fluctuating needs: If your shipping volume varies, a non-asset-based broker can adapt to your changing demands.
• Diverse freight: If you ship a variety of products, the vast network of a broker can ensure you always have the right carrier.
• Cost-consciousness: If you're looking for competitive rates and efficient solutions, a broker's negotiating power can be a huge asset.

‍

Click Logistics: The Best of Both Worlds

‍

At Click Logistics, we understand that choosing between asset-based and non-asset-based transportation can feel like a trade-off. That's why we offer a unique hybrid model that combines the best of both worlds. We have our own fleet of trucks and trailers, giving us the control and capacity to handle your high-priority shipments. But we also have a vast network of trusted carriers, so we can always find the most efficient and cost-effective solution for your specific needs.

‍

Our team of experienced logistics professionals uses cutting-edge technology to optimize your supply chain, from finding the right carriers to tracking your shipments in real time.  Whether you're a small business shipping locally or a large enterprise with complex logistics needs, we have the expertise and resources to help you succeed.

‍

Conclusion

‍

Choosing the right transportation model is crucial for your bottom line. Consider your shipping volume, freight types, budget, and geographic reach to determine whether asset-based or non-asset-based is the best fit for your business.

Remember, there's no one-size-fits-all answer. The right choice depends on your unique needs and goals. That's why we encourage you to contact Click Logistics for a free consultation. Our team of experts can help you assess your options and develop a customized transportation strategy that delivers the results you need.

‍

Don't leave your supply chain success to chance. Make an informed decision and partner with a logistics provider who understands your business and can help you achieve your goals.

‍